HISTORY: Chapter 10, History of Cayuga Co., NY 1879; Cayuga co., NY submitted by W. David Samuelsen *********************************************************************** Copyright. All rights reserved. http://www.usgwarchives.net/copyright.htm http://www.usgwarchives.net/ny/nyfiles.htm *********************************************************************** 1789 - History of Cayuga County, New York, with Illustrations and Biographical Sketches of some of Its Prominent Men and Pioneers, by Elliot G. Storke, assisted by Jas. H. Smith. Pub. by D. Mason & Co., Syracuse, N.Y. 1879 CHAPTER X. PROGRESS OF EDUCATION - SCHOOLS. PHYSICAL AND MENTAL PROGRESS COMPARED -EFFECTS OF PIONEER LIFE - EARLY DISADVANTAGES - SCHOOL BUILDINGS - BOOKS-TEACHERS AND TEACHING - SCHOOL DISCIPLINE - ITS BARBAROUS MODES - INCENTIVES TO STUDY - COUNTY SUPERVISION - IMPROVED SCHOOL BOOKS - TEACHERS' ASSOCIATIONS - INSTITUTES - NORMAL SCHOOLS - PUBLIC SCHOOLS OF AUBURN. The historic records of our County would be incomplete if there were not found in them some account of the means and agencies employed for the intellectual and moral development of the people. If there has not been as manifest and decided progress in the means for the mental, as for the physical improvement of our people, there have, nevertheless, been very decided advances made in the former, as will clearly appear in a review of the early history of our schools. Physical progress, the world over, has always outrun the mental. For this the reasons are obvious. Physical wants are imperious and their supply is necessary to existence. Life depends upon attention to them. Moreover, physical progress is easily seen and appreciated by the simplest observer and its necessity and importance acknowledged. All can see it, for it is manifest to the external senses. The millions that crowded to our Centennial Jubilee, saw with wonder and admiration, understood and appreciated the marvelous creations of the mechanical and artistic genius of the world. In that display, where the genius and skill of cultivated minds were manifested in external and sensible objects, all were interested, as they could appreciate the results of skill and toil applied to material things. But mental and moral progress are less apparent and the means and agencies by which they are affected are not so easily seen. They operate so slowly and so obscurely, and their results are so widely separated from their causes, as to appear only in the lives and characters of the developed man and woman. It has been well said that " the pulsations of a nation's heart are to be counted not by seconds, but by years;" and so the formative effects of culture are fully manifested only in matured lives, and those effects are so far removed from the causes which produced them that their connection is rarely traced except by the educated. It really requires culture to understand the needs and advantages of culture. But our early settlers were surrounded by circumstances quite unfavorable to mental progress. The country was new, the people poor, and all their surroundings demanded close attention in order to meet the absolute wants of their physical natures. While nearly all of the descendants of New England ancestry in this County and in the State, and their number was relatively large, brought with them a love of learning, as they understood it, their conception of the import of the word was very different from ours. To be wholly unlettered was a disgrace ; but to be able to read, write and cipher, was regarded as amply sufficient, and all beyond that, except for the learned professions, was held to be a mere waste of time and money. Of culture, of that discipline and training of the faculties by which the thorough student of today is prepared, solely by the unaided exercise of his own disciplined powers, to go on almost indefinitely in the attainment of knowledge, they knew little. Such was the popular estimate of education among the masses seventy-five years ago. It was the "dark age" in our intellectual history ; dark by reason of the inevitable exclusion of intellectual light. The dense trees of the unbroken forest excluded the sunlight from the soil not more fully, than did the unfavorable surroundings of the settler shut out from his children the light of intelligence ; and this was the common condition of education in the central counties of the State, where the same general causes, the same hindrances and helps operated to produce kindred results. WHY OUR EARLY SCHOOLS WERE POOR. The energies of the first generation were so severely taxed to remove the forests and all the other diversified obstacles which beset them as to leave little opportunity for mental improvement. Discipline of muscle, rather than of mind, was the great demand, imperious physical wants engrossed and compelled attention for many years. The first generation in this County were, nevertheless, thoroughly educated in many very important respects, in lessons not sufficiently taught in the vaunted schools of today. They were taught many of the nobler lessons of true manhood. Their education gave them sound bodies, sterling common sense, pure minds and industrious and economical habits. They were thoroughly schooled in self-denials. A sense of mutual dependence cultivated in nearly all a mutual sympathy and helpfulness. To aid the needy, was a common characteristic, whether in sickness or in the common affairs of life. They were, moreover, homogeneous, had similar habits, tastes and aspirations, and were, mainly, of similar nationalities. As communities, they were kind, social and orderly ; quite unlike the gold-hunters and other speculating adventurers of to-day, or the recent immigrants of diverse, and often opposing nationalities and creeds, who have since thronged our shores, filled our towns, or spread over our broad domains. The early settlers of this County and State also differed greatly both from the settlers of Plymouth and from those who have recently formed, and now form, the great bulk of our western settlers. The settlers of Plymouth comprised a large proportion of thoroughly educated men, capable of organizing the State, the church and even the university. The leading minds in that community were men of marked individuality, distinguished alike for boldness of thought and independence of action. They had fled from tyranny at home to seek freedom of opinion here, at the cost of privation and hardship ; and New England owes to those bold, brave spirits, much of the prestige which she has always maintained in politics, religion and learning. But the struggles and privations of a new country for a century and a half, while they did not lessen the enterprise and vigor of their descendants who successively tenanted new region's, took from them the means of mental culture, so that, for several generations, instead of progress, there was really a retrogression of learning. But the West was mostly peopled by those who lived at the East after the "revival of learning," and had carried with them, and planted along our western parallels, a more enlightened and liberal system of instruction, perfected during the period from 1830 to 1860. EARLY DISADVANTAGES. The children of the first settlers of this County opened their eyes upon rude surroundings. Those settlers lived in log houses and, generally, were descendants of pioneers in other places, who for a generation or more had combated similar difficulties. Their own education was limited. They themselves felt the need of more thorough instruction, and were anxious to give it to their children. But how could this be done ? Where were the books, or the teachers ? Suitable books, for the instruction of children and youth had not been introduced and competent teachers were not in the County. But schools they must, and schools they did, maintain, for longer or shorter periods each year. A brief glance at the early school buildings, school books, the teachers at their daily work, and their method of discipline and instruction, will show the early condition of our schools. OUR EARLY SCHOOL BUILDINGS, like the homes of the children, were generally of logs. The windows were small and far between, the otherwise deficient light being supplied by the capacious chimneys, and by crevices in the walls and ceilings. This is no fancy picture ; nor need we go any further back in our history than 1844 to find full counterparts of just such school buildings, still in use in this County. They were fully described in the reports of the supervisory officers of that day. In such buildings our ancestors in this County received their first lessons; among them was one who became president of the United States. (1) On dark days the pupils would be arranged before, and around the base of, the large chimney, utilizing the light which poured down its capacious throat, and without which, study would have been impossible. The floor and ceiling were of loose, rough boards, through the joints of which the wind would freely circulate, affording an abundance of fresh air. The seats were often formed of riven portions of forest trees, or, where saw mills existed, of planks or slabs, supported at either end by roughly formed and acute angled legs, and without backs. Those legs would often seek in vain for a secure rest upon the uneven floor, but without doing so. From such seats, sufficiently high for adults, dangled for six tedious hours daily, the uneasy limbs of children from four to six years of age, with no support for either the legs, arms or backs. Here they must cling to the plank, or slab, and keep quiet, under the penalty of a blow from the whip, or ferrule, of the master, or mistress, of ceremonies. When weary, and they would soon become so, sleep would over-take, not only their limbs, in which the circulation was impeded by the sharp-angled seats, but also their entire bodies, and a careless rock of the uneasy seat would precipitate the sleepers to the floor. But the broad open fire-places of those primitive school rooms were objects of the highest interest. It was not alone the light which they supplied, grateful and necessary as that often was ; they were miniature bon-fires, on which the otherwise under lighted eyes of the pupils rested with pleasure. They would gorge, at once, and without crowding, a full quarter of a cord of wood, and, when in full blast, glowed like the log heaps of the settlers' fallow ground. Around the blazing pile, the pupils on their entrance would range themselves, and, by repeated turnings, would at length so saturate with warmth their thick, home-made clothing as, for a short time, to be comfortable upon their seats, but for a short time only ; for " may I go to the fire ? " was, on cold days, the constant cry of the pupils. In summer those open fire-places were beautifully adorned by the skill and taste of the sylvan mistress, with various green branches from the near forest, and with such wild flowers as the season afforded. Carving was one of the arts into which the school boys of that day were thoroughly indoctrinated, and the use of the pocket-knife was well understood by them; for "The Yankee boy before he's sent to school Well knows the uses of that magic_tool, The pocket-knife," and the benches and forms of all the early school rooms were honey-combed by his industry. Not having congenial employment for his head, he sought and found it for his hands. Such were the general condition of the school houses of the County, for a full generation after its first settlement, and very many of the same sort existed as late as 1840. THE SCHOOL BOOKS. - It should be remembered that at the time, and for many years after the first settlement of the County, books of any kind were a luxury rarely seen in the homes of the people, excepting the family Bible and hymn book, and the annual calendar, or almanac. School books were then very few, and confined to the three subjects, of reading, spelling and arithmetic ; the latter for the boys in all cases, but not always for the girls. The girls, it was thought, were sufficiently educated if they were taught to read and write. Their fathers, brothers, or husbands could do the " reckoning" for them. The first books were of English production. Dilworth's spelling book and arithmetic had been generally used in New England, and many of them found their way into the early schools of this County, having descended to the children from the parents, who had used them. Webster's Spelling Book, published in 1783, was the first American school book printed in this country, and it soon found its way into our schools to the exclusion of nearly every other spelling book, and became the constant companion of all the pupils, from their entrance to their exit, and they were so long and so thoroughly drilled upon it that some pupils would recite half the words contained in it. The New Testament was a common reading book in the earlier periods into which the pupil graduated directly from the spelling book. There were then no "grades " in the schools, or any first, second, third, fourth, fifth and sixth readers, as at the present day. Usually one reading book sufficed ; but pupils would read in whatever book the parents might send, no matter what its title or subject. It might be Robinson Crusoe, or Pilgrims Progress ; and it was all the same, if there was but one book of the kind in the school. Webster's Spelling Book, however, soon became nearly universal. Murray's English Reader and the Columbian Orator followed, and were fixtures in the schools for a full quarter of a century. These books comprised the finest classical productions of the men of the age; but were utterly unsuited for the children into whose hands they were placed, and who mumbled and stumbled through their classic paragraphs, with as little comprehension of them, as though they had been written in a dead language. But it should be remembered that comprehension of a lesson, at that time, was not considered important ; that was not the object. The pupils were then taught simply to read, not to comprehend. They were too young to understand the lesson, but would do so when they were older. This false and pernicious error ran through every study. Lessons were put into the hands of a child of eight years of age, which developed minds only could comprehend. TEACHERS AND TEACHING. It will be con-ceded that the teachers of that day, as a class, were not competent to their work, nor their instruction guided by any intelligent rules. They had been very imperfectly educated, and could not teach others what they did not know them-selves. The very perfect text-books of to-day supply largely the deficiencies of teachers ; but then both teachers and text-books were deficient, and the result was what we have described. But all the schools and teachers of the first generation were not equally inefficient. There were in the hamlets and villages a few well educated teachers, who were good instructors ; and fine scholars have graduated from even our early backwoods schools ; geniuses, whom no obstacles could repress, and whose peculiar mental vigor led them on to conquer every obstacle in their paths. The early school discipline was but a counter-part of the prevailing errors of the time. It was mainly physical. The whip and the ferrule were as constant companions to the teacher as the book, or the pen. The book in his hand, the whip or ferrule under his arm, and the pen over his ear, all were equally intended for use. The pupils were urged to be orderly and diligent by pungent and often painful persuasion. A goodly store of well seasoned switches was al-ways ready for extra occasions, when, as often happened, wholesale floggings were to be inflicted. The whip in the hand of the teacher fell frequently upon the mischievous or the idle, and generally without warning or explanation. This impromptu discipline and the thorough preparation of the teachers for offense or defense, created in many schools a state of merely suspended warfare ; the relations between the teacher and the pupils being essentially belligerent, and liable at any time to break out into open warfare. In the teacher, therefore, strong physical pro-portions and firm courage were very necessary to success. On the entrance of a new teacher, he would be as carefully scanned as competitors in the prize ring, not to estimate his mind, manners, or morals, but the power of his muscles, and the probable chances of success if a conflict should arise. With young pupils the whip and the ferrule were supplemented by many ingenious yet cruel devices, a gag in the mouth, a most barbarous punishment, standing on one foot, holding an object in the extended or uplifted hand, resting one hand and one foot upon the floor, holding a heavy weight in both hands, the body inclined forward. These and many other cruel tortures which the law forbids to be inflicted upon the felons in our prisons, were regularly used for more than a generation in Cayuga County, to in-cite in children the love of order, of books and of schools. Is their general failure a wonder ? Incentives to study, as we have just shown, were mainly coercive, but emulation and rewards were also employed ; emulation mainly confined to the spelling exercises, and rewards to the primaries, place taking in spelling, and simple gifts to the small children. The post of honor, the head of the spelling class, was eagerly sought for, and, in the absence of other proper incentives, doubtless benefitted the brighter pupils, who usually would carry off the palm ; but the less gifted were depressed by thus constantly publishing their inferiority in the little community in which they daily moved. Emulation was also employed in an interesting and exciting form in the process termed " spelling down," an exercise still continued ; but the greatest interest centered in the spelling schools of the time, which for the lads and lasses, had connected with them more pleasant and endearing associations than any or all of the other school exercises. Of all the studies pursued in our early schools, reading was the most imperfectly taught. The unnatural, listless, drawling monotone in prose, or the sing-song in poetry, was nearly universal. It was the result of a habit formed in childhood, continued and confirmed in youth, and immovably fixed in manhood. So general was this habit of expressionless reading that a good reader was seldom heard. The schools tended only to form and fix tile habit, and books and newspapers were so rare that home reading. except of the Bible, was little practiced, and the idea that the Bible must be read in a peculiarly solemn tone did not help to form good readers. Among the masses of the people of this County for about a quarter of a century, good reading had nearly become one of the "lost arts" It was, at least, but imperfectly preserved, amid the rigid demands and privations of forest life. Arithmetic was better taught. Its utility was apparent to all, and every boy was initiated into its mysteries, or rather its mummeries, for its mysteries were seldom revealed. Its operations were largely mechanical, yet so long and continuous was the drill that most of the boys could " do the sums " as far as the " rule of three," be-fore they left school. Each pupil was taught singly without classes or blackboards. Indeed, in 1842, there were but two blackboards in the entire County. It was a slow and laborious operation for the teacher to " work out" the various " sums " for the pupils on their slates as models for them to imitate, for the progress was chiefly one of imitation, the pupils, by long practice learning to follow their teacher's model or method of solving the questions under the different " rules." " Please show me how to do this sum ?" was a question constantly repeated in all the early schools. It would be interesting to compare the copy-books and the facilities for acquiring the art of writing, existing in our schools fifty to seventy-five years ago, with those of to-day. The pupils came with home-made copy-books of coarse, unruled paper, varying in quantity from one to a half dozen sheets, home-made inks compounded of domestic dyes, a flat lead pencil formed of hammered lead, a goose quill and a ruler. Ready-made writing books, ruled paper and steel pens were yet in the future. Pens were " made" and copies " set " by the teacher. " Please make" or " Please mend my pen," were regular appeals to the teacher. In cold weather, the fire-place would, each morning, be surrounded by ink-stands to thaw their frozen contents. The teachers generally were clumsy penmen, and being changed every few months, there were very few decent chirographers among the pupils. This rude condition of our popular schools was gradually changed. The rapid increase of our population, averaging for the first thirty years more than twelve hundred per year, led to a corresponding improvement in the means and condition of the people. Hamlets and villages arose and educated men in large numbers became residents of them. The professions and most of the employments soon had in them men of liberal attainments, whose children were to be educated. Nearly all of this class were the organizers ,and patrons of private schools, the popular schools not being at that time, in their judgment, or in fact, worthy of intelligent patronage. Hence, though there were a few educated and competent teachers thus employed in the instruction of the children of the more intelligent, the public schools were still neglected, and in them very little improvement was made. From 1789 to 1838, the State from time to time, from the sale of lotteries, appropriations of public lands, and from revenues derived from United States deposit funds and other sources, had been accumulating a fund, the income of which was annually appropriated to the support of common schools. This fund in 1838 amounted to over three-fourths of a million of dollars. From the administration of Governor George Clinton, every Governor and Secretary of State has advocated and recommended a liberal encouragement of common schools, and laws for their internal administration have been enacted, and from time to time changed. The first general law was passed in 1795. It appropriated $50,000 annually, for five years, to the support of the common schools. Each county was required to raise by tax an amount equal to one-half its distributive share of this sum, and town commissioners and district trustees were authorized to be appointed. On this subject, at that time, Governor Clinton said : "While it is evident that the general establishment and liberal endowment of academies are highly to be commended and are attended with the most beneficial results ; yet it cannot be denied that they are principally confined to the children of the opulent, and that a great portion of the community are excluded from their needed advantages. The establishment of common schools throughout the State is happily calculated to remedy this inconvenience, and will, therefore, engage your early and decided consideration." The same liberal support was given to the common schools by Governors Jay, in 1800, Clinton, in 1802, Lewis, in 1805, and Tompkins, during his administration, and defects in the laws were sought to be corrected. In 1811 a commission was appointed by the Legislature, consisting of five persons, to revise the system of common school organization, whose report in 1812 was adopted, and Gideon Hawley was appointed State Superintendent, which position he held until 1821, when the Secretary of State was made ex-officio Superintendent of Schools. But the practical operation of the school system of the State was far from satisfactory. At-tempts were regularly made to correct defects. Eight academies, one in each Senatorial district, were designated in 1835, for the instruction of common-school teachers. District school libraries were established in 1838 ; and in 1841 the supervision of the schools was confided to Deputy or County Superintendents. In 1843 Town Inspectors and Commissioners were superceded by one Superintendent of Schools in each town. A State Normal School was organized in 1844, especially intended for the instruction of common school teachers, and opened on the 18th of December following. The office of County Superintendent was continued for six years, and had been the means of effecting important improvements in the schools, but the appointments, made by the County Supervisors, were, in some instances, injudicious, and the office was brought into disrepute and abolished in 1847, against the earnest protest of the best friends of education in the State. It was, however, practically restored in 1856, by the institution of the office of School Commissioner, which is still continued. Free schools throughout the State were established in 1849, the act being submitted to the people, by three-fourths of whom it was approved. Its practical operation was found to impose unequal taxation and a re-submission of the law to a popular vote was demanded. In 1850 the vote was taken, and the law again sustained, but by a lessened majority. The free school law was abolished the year following, and the provision was made to raise $$800,000 annually, by State tax, which was afterwards changed to a three-fourths mill tax, by which the country schools were mainly relieved from rate bills. The establishment of free, union, or high schools was permitted by law in 1853. There has, therefore, been no lack of interest in education on the part of the State, and it has, from first to last, liberally contributed to its support and advancement. But the great difficulty has been amongst the people them-selves, as to the right use and application of the means provided, and a lack of intelligent comprehension of the best method of giving to their schools the highest efficiency. Between 1830 and 1850 is the period during which thorough improvements in our schools had their origin ; and the first important impulse was given by the introduction of improved school books, prepared by intelligent educators. In that period, also, the range of studies was greatly enlarged. Grammar, geography, natural philosophy and algebra found their way into the common schools, and chemistry, botany, astronomy, geology and mental and moral philosophy, into our public high schools. Much of the credit of this reform must be con-ceded to that now troublesome and importunate class, the authors and publishers of school books. There was a great need of better books, and authors and publishers came in swarms to supply it. Each author, or publisher, acting as critic of the defects of rival books, and as instructor in the great method of teaching the subjects embraced in his own. This gradually led to a more careful consideration of the whole subject and was the first step in educational reform. There was a coincident and great change in the educational literature for children and youth, of which the "Peter Parley" and the "Abott's Books" were examples, and of which millions of copies were sold, and whose influence upon the young was most wholesome. S. G. Goodrich, the author of the Peter Parley books, who wrote more books for youth than any other American, and who has been called the " Napoleon of the Pen," gave, in four lines, the " Golden Rules" which should be the guide of the educator, whether parent or professional teacher. "Begin with simple lessons-things On which the children love to look; Flowers, insects, pebbles, birds on wings, These are God's spelling book." Between 1830 and 1850 was also the period during which education and the best means for its improvement formed the great subject of discussion, in which were engaged the ripest scholars and soundest educators of the age : Emerson, Mann, Woodbridge, Alonzo Potter, David P. Paige, and scores of others. They prepared masterly papers or books, which were widely disseminated over the country, enlightening the public and leading to the institution of the county supervision of our schools in 1841, the establishment of teachers' institutes in 1842, of the State Normal School for the special training of teachers, in 1844, followed by seven other similar institutions in different parts of the State, and of provisions for the free education of all the youth of the State a few years later. The county supervision of the public schools, established in 1841, was the most efficient agency that had theretofore been employed to reform their great deficiencies. The officers entrusted with this duty, became among the people educational missionaries, carrying into all the schools the usages and practices of the best educators and acting as the instructors of both teachers and patrons. The people of the several districts were frequently convened, and the wants and deficiencies of the schools and the means of sup-plying them carefully pointed out. The teachers themselves were separately convened in county meetings and practical teaching discussed. Regular teachers' associations arose from these meetings and have been continued to the present time, forming important links in the chain of reform ; but the limited time to which these meetings were restricted, prevented a satisfactory consideration of the various topics presented. Teachers' institutes were a direct and necessary outgrowth of these associations in which the teachers of a county were held in an annual session of about two weeks and carefully instructed by competent educators in the science and art of teaching. The first teachers' institute in the State was held in 1842. They were held in Cayuga County among the earliest, and at the first three sessions there was an attendance of over five hundred teachers. These institutes so enlisted the public favor that they have been regularly maintained for the last thirty-five years, have been recognized, and in part sustained by the State, and organized in most of the counties. They were held in 1877 in fifty-five counties, at which there was an attendance of 11,892 teachers. In 1845, coincident with or very soon after the formation of teachers' associations and institutes in the counties, the State teachers' association was formed and has since been maintained. The County and State association and teachers' institutes were accompanied by the organization in 1843, of a State Normal School, located at Albany, and specially designed for the training of public school teachers. It was so satisfactory in its results that it was afterwards followed by seven similar institutions in other parts of the State, and they are to-day in active and efficient operation. The free school system of the State and of its cities and villages, was also the direct outgrowth of the educational activity during the decade from 1840 to 1850. The results of all these agencies have been a. marvelous change in many of the common and high schools of the State, and Cayuga County has not fallen behind in the march of improvement. Her public schools, especially in the city of Auburn and in the principal villages, that in 1840 were " a by-word and reproach," not patronized by the wealthy and the intelligent, nor worthy of it, are now the recipients of the patronage of all classes, and, for the right instruction of children and youth, are, beyond question, the best schools in the County. In the city of Auburn, the change has been the most marked and decided, and is mainly due to the intelligent and persistent efforts of a few devoted men, amongst whom C. P. Williams, long a teacher in the city and officially connected with the administration of the schools holds a conspicuous place. B. B. Snow, under whose quiet but thorough course as superintendent for many years, the schools have constantly improved, deserves special mention for the important aid which he has rendered and is rendering in school reform. The board of education of the city, to whom, by law, are confided the care and management of the schools, are so soon convinced of their efficiency by personal inspection, as to lead them cheer-fully to adopt the measures necessary to maintain it. The greatest improvement arose from the institution of the academic high school, which is the rallying point of the hopes, and goal of the ambition of all the grades below it. Few, in-deed, may enter it, yet most of the pupils hope and strive to do so, and it is a constant stimulant to all in the public schools. Much has been done for the improvement of popular education in Cayuga County ; yet " eternal vigilance" is necessary to maintain and perpetuate it. (1) Millard Fillmore.