USGENWEB NOTICE:  In keeping with our policy of providing free information
on the Internet, data may be freely used by non-commercial entities, as long
as this message remains on all copied material. These electronic pages may
NOT be reproduced in any format for profit or presentation by other
organizations.

page016

		ATTEMPTED HOLD UP ENDS IN TRAGEDY[?]

		    [Picture of 1 Boy and 2 men]

	Princibals in Saturday night's hold up and shooting.
Reading from left to right. Eugene Doty, 15 year old son of Chas.
Doty; Oliver Lightner, the victim; and Chas. Doty, who killed
Lightner.
				(Courtesy of Lima News)

	YOUNG BLUFFTON MAN IS KILLED SATURDAY MIDNIGHT IN
 	    HIS EFFORT TO ROB CHAS. M. DOTY AND SON

Eugene Doty's Presence of Mind Thwarts Bandit's Purpose and Saves
Father's Life.

	A small patch of blood on Ottawa street just across from
Gettman's residence, marks the spot where Oliver Lightner of
Bluffton breathed his last. Four bullets from the pistol of Chas.
Doty had crashed thru his body, three of them thru the chest and
one thru his thigh. Lightner died within a few feet from where he
boldly attempted to hold up Mr. Doty and his son last Saturday at
about midnight.
	Doty and son Eugene (Jim) were on their way home from his
place of business, the pool room, and carried with them a large
amount of money in checks and currency. When they arrived at
Cross street they noticed a suspicious looking character pass in
fron of them. Doty who always carried a loaded weapon with im
when on his way home at nights, prepared himself for any
emergency that might come up. He took his revolver and held it
concealed in his overcoat pocket. When they reached a place just
opposite the Gettman home, a masked bandit leaped from behind a
large tree and held a pistol in their faces, asking them to throw up 
their hands. Eugene realizing what was happening, and with great presence 
of mind, reached out for the bandits arms and shoved them upward.
In the meantime Chas. Doty, the father dodged to the left and
fired three successive shots thru the man's body, each one
piercing the chest within a few inches from each other. A fourth
shot was fired which passed thru his left thigh. The man fell
against the fence to the walk, Both father and son went for help.
Marshall Johnson reached the spot within three minutes after the
shooting. The man had in the meantime crawled off the sidewalk on
to the street and was lying on his face. Johnson took off the
mask and only noticed the lips move but no words was heard from
the dying man. He died in the marshall's arms. Drs. Butt and Sink
were called but could not render any assistance. Many of the
neighbors who heard the shooting arrived at the scene armed with
all kinds of weapons.
	The body was taken to Humphreys and Son's undertaking
establishment where he was identified by Luther Sommer of
Pandora.
	Lightner had his face blackned to conceal identity and
had a red bandanna handkerchief tied over the lower part of his
face. He wore an overcoat which he had received, it is claimed,
from Thut of Bluffton who was a pal of his. He carried an
automatic revolver which was loaded, with safety cock released
and ready for action. No shot had been fired from his weapon.
	The parents of the slain boy Mr. and Mrs. William
Lightner of Bluffton were immediately notified of the tragedy and
were prostrate over the terrible news.
	The body remained her until early Sunday morning when it
was taken to Bluffton by Comb's hearse.
	Oliver Lightner was a senior in the Bluffton high school
and about 19 years of age. Whether he had ever attempted any such
deeds prvious to this one is not known. He comes from a very
respectable family and only his outside environment could have
produced such a character. It is suspected that a number of other
young men in the neighorhood of Bluffton were implicated in the
hold up and a very thoro effort is being made to catch those who
may have been connected with Lightner. A machine was seen running
back and forth immediately after the tragedy but no one could
ascertain as to who the occupants were.
	Mr. Doty acted in self defense and the witnesses of the
tragedy can testify as to his actions, thus exonerating him from
blame or penalty.
	The funeral services were held at the parents home in
Bluffton and burial took place in Maple Grove cemetery.